Does a patent need a human inventor?

AI Creation
Last Updated: October 12, 2025
Updated by: Chris Buntel

Table Of Content

[vc_row][vc_column][vc_row_inner][vc_column_inner width=”1/2″][vc_column_text]Everyone has been excited about AI lately (including Tangibly with its impressive “Patent X-Ray” analysis tool).

As usual, the legal system struggles to keep up with technology. AI is no different – many interesting and difficult questions are emerging at breakneck speed this year.

The US Supreme Court recently refused to review a CAFC holding that ruled that patents must have a human inventor, and cannot be awarded to inventions created by AI. A neural network AI created new prototypes for a beverage holder and emergency beacon light on its own without a human “co-inventor”.

[/vc_column_text][/vc_column_inner][vc_column_inner width=”1/2″][us_image image=”310″ has_ratio=”1″ ratio=”16×9″ css=”%7B%22default%22%3A%7B%22margin-bottom%22%3A%222rem%22%7D%7D”][/vc_column_inner][/vc_row_inner][vc_column_text]Similarly on the copyright front, the US copyright office recently rejected an AI-created image as lacking “human authorship”. This is actually similar to the famous “monkey selfie” litigation from a few years ago, that said that animals cannot copyright and litigate.

So where do these cases leave us regarding creative outputs and inventions made by AI? This should be an active and interesting field to watch over the next few years.


Sources:

https://www.supremecourt.gov/search.aspx?filename=/docket/docketfiles/html/public/22-919.html

https://www.copyright.gov/rulings-filings/review-board/docs/a-recent-entrance-to-paradise.pdf[/vc_column_text][/vc_column][/vc_row]

from our blog

Reasonable Measures Podcast, AI & IP

Episode 19: From Copyright to Trade Secrets: Anthropic’s Impact on AI & IP

In this episode Tim and Chris unpack the Inevitable Disclosure Doctrine, a century old trade secret rule that began in 1902 when a sugar refinery worker was blocked...
SIM IP and Tangibly
Blog, Featured Blogs, Guest Author Series, Press, Trade Secret Strategy

A New Era for Trade Secret Enforcement: Tangibly Announces Strategic Investment from SIM IP

Tangibly Announces Strategic Investment from SIM IP At Tangibly, our mission has always been clear: to empower companies to protect their most valuable innovations. We...
Blog, Featured Blogs, Trade Secret Strategy

Takeaways: Leveraging Trade Secrets for New Revenue Streams

A summary and key takeaways from the IAM Q3 2025 Special Report – Unlocking Trade Secret Strategies IAM’s Q3 2025 Special Report Unlocking Trade Secret Strategies...
Blog, AI & IP, Featured Blogs, Guest Author Series

When to patent and when to keep AI innovations secret

When to patent and when to keep AI innovations secret Artificial intelligence is reshaping industries at breakneck speed, from healthcare diagnostics to creative...
Blog, Trade Secret Strategy

The Silent Heist: Why Trade Secret Theft Often Goes Unpunished

Trade secrets are the lifeblood of innovation, the hidden recipes, proprietary processes, and confidential customer lists that give a business its competitive edge....
Blog, AI & IP, Featured Blogs, Guest Author Series

AI-Powered Protein Engineering Is Forcing Next-Gen IP Strategy and Competitive Analysis

AI-Powered Protein Engineering Is Forcing Next-Gen IP Strategy and Competitive Analysis Authors: Celeste Alvarez, Makda Gebre and Alex Harwig AI isn’t just predicting...
Blog, Guest Author Series, Release Notes

Streamlining Trade Secret Programs with SSO Integration

Tangibly is excited to announce the rollout of Single Sign-On (SSO) integration with Entra (Azure AD), Google, and Okta. This milestone is not just about stronger...
Blog, Featured Blogs, Guest Author Series, Trade Secret Strategy

Thoughts on Expanding the Scope of Reasonable Measures

In our experience “reasonable measures” to protect trade secrets has been historically grounded in legal and compliance frameworks. “Reasonableness” was primarily...
Reasonable Measures Podcast

Episode 18: When Trade Secrets Drive M&A featuring Ray Miller

In this episode Tim and Chris unpack the Inevitable Disclosure Doctrine, a century old trade secret rule that began in 1902 when a sugar refinery worker was blocked...
Reasonable Measures Podcast

Episode 17: The Lifecycle of Trade Secret Protection featuring Raluca David

In this episode Tim and Chris unpack the Inevitable Disclosure Doctrine, a century old trade secret rule that began in 1902 when a sugar refinery worker was blocked...