How do you like them apples?

Understanding Whistleblower Immunity Under the Defend Trade Secrets Act (DTSA)
Last Updated: December 9, 2025
Updated by: Chris Buntel

Table Of Content

The latest in our “trade secrets are everywhere” mantra…

Soon after we wrote about trade secrets in liquor production, we have a widely-reported trade secret misappropriation incident between beer & cider manufacturers.

A manager of IT, sales, and business analysis for Boston Beer Co. (maker of Sam Adams and Angry Orchard) voluntarily left the company in April 2023 to join Downeast Cider House as Senior VP of Marketing.

Boston Beer warned him that joining Downeast Cider would violate his employment agreement. They also notified the founder of Downeast Cider that if they hire the individual, he will be in breach of his pre-existing employment agreement.

Just before leaving, our intrepid IT manager connected an external device to his company computer and accessed files including market plans, sales performance, pricing guides, budgets, and branding documents.

Boston Beer sued both the individual and Downeast in October 2023 for a long laundry list of causes including: breach of non-compete, non-disclosure, a training repayment clause, intentional interference with contract, misappropriation of trade secrets, breach of fiduciary duty, and unjust enrichment. Boston Beer also asked for a preliminary injunction preventing the individual from working for Downeast for one year and to not disclose Boston Beer’s confidential information.

Interestingly the complaint was not filed in federal court under DTSA, but instead was filed in Massachusetts state courts under UTSA. This litigation is just getting up to speed, and will be interesting watch while enjoying the hard cider of your choice…

Read the complaint here: https://www.universalhub.com/files/bostonbeer2-complaint.pdf

from our blog

Blog, AI & IP, Featured Blogs, Guest Author Series

The AI IP Gold Rush Meets the § 101 Minefield

We are living in an artificial intelligence (AI) gold rush. From large language models that write code to machine learning systems that optimize logistics or predict...
Blog, AI & IP

Can AI be an inventor? USPTO clarifies the role of human inventors

The USPTO issued new inventorship guidance for AI assisted inventions on November 28, 2025, relating to the hot topic of AI-assisted inventions.  Please note that this...
Blog

Does writing an AI prompt make you an inventor?

Your AI prompt is not enough! In the patent world, it is well settled that merely posing a problem or a challenge is not enough to make you an inventor of the...
Blog

Protecting Programs, Data and Trade Secrets

Programs and data are no longer just technical assets. They are trade secrets. They encompass the algorithms, processes, customer insights, models, and confidential...
Blog, Intellectual Property & Patent Insights, Intro to Trade Secrets

Patent Attorney vs. Trade Secret Strategist: Which Expert Do You Need First?

If you think about it, everything starts out as a trade secret, even patents. It is more important to first consider your trade secret strategy before deploying your...
Blog, Intro to Trade Secrets

A Guide to Building a Robust Trade Secret Program

In the relentless chess match of modern business, your most valuable assets aren't always the ones on your balance sheet. They are the secret formulas, the proprietary...
Blog, Featured Blogs, Guest Author Series, Trade Secret Strategy

The Invisible Epidemic: Unprosecuted Trade Secret Theft and the Path to Protection

The Invisible Epidemic: Unprosecuted Trade Secret Theft and the Path to Protection In a recent LinkedIn post that sparked discussion among IP experts and entrepreneurs,...
Blog

What AI Governance Frameworks Should Organizations Implement?

As artificial intelligence becomes central to product development and operations, companies must put in place governance frameworks that protect their trade secrets and...
Blog

Policy and Investment Recommendations for Trustworthy AI

As artificial intelligence charges forward at an incredible pace, organizations find themselves on a tightrope, balancing lightning fast innovation with the crucial...
Blog

When to Bring in a Patent Attorney (and How to Prepare)

Protecting your innovation isn't a one size fits all game. Between patents, trade secrets, copyrights, and trademarks, deciding when to involve a patent attorney can...