Does a patent need a human inventor?

Understanding Whistleblower Immunity Under the Defend Trade Secrets Act (DTSA)
Last Updated: February 12, 2026
Updated by: Chris Buntel

Table Of Content

Everyone has been excited about AI lately (including Tangibly with its impressive “Patent X-Ray” analysis tool).

As usual, the legal system struggles to keep up with technology. AI is no different – many interesting and difficult questions are emerging at breakneck speed this year.

The US Supreme Court recently refused to review a CAFC holding that ruled that patents must have a human inventor, and cannot be awarded to inventions created by AI. A neural network AI created new prototypes for a beverage holder and emergency beacon light on its own without a human “co-inventor”.

Similarly on the copyright front, the US copyright office recently rejected an AI-created image as lacking “human authorship”. This is actually similar to the famous “monkey selfie” litigation from a few years ago, that said that animals cannot copyright and litigate.

So where do these cases leave us regarding creative outputs and inventions made by AI? This should be an active and interesting field to watch over the next few years.


Sources:

https://www.supremecourt.gov/search.aspx?filename=/docket/docketfiles/html/public/22-919.html

https://www.copyright.gov/rulings-filings/review-board/docs/a-recent-entrance-to-paradise.pdf

from our blog

Blog, AI & IP, Intellectual Property & Patent Insights, Trade Secret Strategy

What is litigation funding?

With the recent press release from SIM IP and Tangibly, a client recently asked me a simple but important question: how does litigation funding actually work? The...
Blog, Featured Blogs, Guest Author Series, Press, Trade Secret Strategy

SIM IP and Tangibly Launch Trade Secret Litigation Financing Partnership

Miami – Jan 15, 2026 – Sauvegarder Investment Management, Inc. (“SIM IP”), a global leader in intellectual property-based investment and monetization, and Tangibly, an...
Blog, AI & IP, Featured Blogs, Intellectual Property & Patent Insights, Trade Secret Strategy

When AI patent tools become the most valuable trade secrets

A newly filed lawsuit in the Northern District of California centers on alleged trade secret misappropriation involving an AI powered patent analysis and management...
Blog, AI & IP, Intellectual Property & Patent Insights, Trade Secret Strategy

To patent or not to patent?

To patent or not to patent, that is the right question. Don’t get us at Tangibly started on “patent vs. trade secret” or “patent or trade secret”.  There’s no reason...
Blog, AI & IP, Featured Blogs, Guest Author Series

The AI IP Gold Rush Meets the § 101 Minefield

We are living in an artificial intelligence (AI) gold rush. From large language models that write code to machine learning systems that optimize logistics or predict...
Blog, AI & IP

Can AI be an inventor? USPTO clarifies the role of human inventors

The USPTO issued new inventorship guidance for AI assisted inventions on November 28, 2025, relating to the hot topic of AI-assisted inventions.  Please note that this...
Blog

Does writing an AI prompt make you an inventor?

Your AI prompt is not enough! In the patent world, it is well settled that merely posing a problem or a challenge is not enough to make you an inventor of the...
Blog

Protecting Programs, Data and Trade Secrets

Programs and data are no longer just technical assets. They are trade secrets. They encompass the algorithms, processes, customer insights, models, and confidential...
Blog, Intellectual Property & Patent Insights, Intro to Trade Secrets

Patent Attorney vs. Trade Secret Strategist: Which Expert Do You Need First?

If you think about it, everything starts out as a trade secret, even patents. It is more important to first consider your trade secret strategy before deploying your...
Blog, Intro to Trade Secrets

A Guide to Building a Robust Trade Secret Program

In the relentless chess match of modern business, your most valuable assets aren't always the ones on your balance sheet. They are the secret formulas, the proprietary...